Google’s John Mueller Warns Fluff Content Can Harm Your Law Firm’s Whole Site

BY Bigger Law Firm Magazine

Fluff Content AI Articles for Law Firms
  • Google’s John Mueller warns that publishing low-quality, fluffy content can negatively impact a website’s overall search engine performance, as search algorithms may assume the entire site has mediocre content.
  • Mueller calls out gen-AI content but does not mention ChatGPT or Google Bard by name.
  • Studies and articles emphasize the importance of prioritizing content quality over quantity, as higher-quality content leads to better online visibility and client acquisition, particularly for law firms.
  • To improve your website’s search engine performance, focus on consistently producing valuable, informative content tailored to your target audience’s needs rather than solely aiming for a high volume of content.


Google's John Mueller has issued a warning to website owners, emphasizing that publishing fluffy, low-quality content can have detrimental effects on the overall site's performance in search engine rankings. In today's fast-paced marketing world, it's tempting to prioritize content quantity over quality. However, Mueller's statement reminds us that quality should always be the primary focus to ensure long-term success in the online realm.

John Mueller recently answered questions on the r/BigSEO subreddit.

To the question "Blogging. If we do it, is it everyday or once a week with some seriously solid stuff?" He replied:

“The problem with trying to keep a frequency up is that it’s easy to end up with mediocre, fluffy content, which search engine quality algorithms might pick up on, and then assume the whole site is like that.

Taking risks like this in the beginning when it’s easy for you to start over is probably fine, doing that in the long run will be painful when it catches up to you. (All of this applies even more if you’re taking short-cuts with gen-ai content).”

Mueller's warning makes it clear that the risks of fluff content are not worth taking, especially as your law firm's website grows and gains traction.

What is fluff content?

Fluff content is any type of content that is low-quality, low-value, and does not provide any real benefit to the reader. It is often characterized by:

  • Plagiarism or copied content
  • Poor grammar and spelling
  • Vague or unsubstantiated claims
  • Lack of original research
  • Too much promotional content
  • Too little substance
  • Generic AI generated content

Consistency is Good.

Maintaining a consistent publishing schedule is important as readers like to know they can rely on a predictable amount of information from their favorite sources. But they're also willing to wait for solid information, which is why prioritizing content quality over quantity should be the primary goal for your law firm's website. Remember, anybody can type in a prompt to ChatGPT like "Write a blog about what to do after a car accident in Texas" and generate the same over-written concept that Google has seen in its index a million times.

But only your law firm can turn your attorneys' experiences into unique content that brings new and interesting insights to the web.

By heeding John Mueller's warning and focusing on producing valuable, informative content for your audience, you can avoid the pitfalls of fluff content and improve your website's overall search engine performance.

Bigger Law Firm Magazine

Bigger Law Firm Magazine has been helping law firms grow since 2011. We regularly publish helpful insights from industry professionals to help legal marketing directors, firm administrators, and lawyers build bigger and more efficient law firms.


A canary generated by OpenAI's Dall-E

What Larry, the Hairy Canary Can Teach Us About ChatGPT’s Ability to Generate Unique Content

OpenAI’s ChatGPT bot has been generating a lot of buzz. But can it generate unique content, over, and over, and over again? To find out, we created a fictional character named Larry, the Hairy Canary and asked ChatGPT to write a poem… and then another poem. And then another. Over the course of our tests…

YouTube Handles for Law Firms

Getting a Handle on YouTube Handles for Lawyers

One of the profound ways social media have shaped all our lives is by making networking and connecting conveniently.

Lawyer focusing on content

How Law Firm Marketing Directors Can Keep Attorneys Focused on Content

Content is an essential part of a successful law firm marketing strategy, and it is important that attorneys respect the necessary time investment.