Share.

For a law firm, being in the 3-pack (top 3 rankings in the map on the search results page) for your specific practice area's keywords is the holy grail in search marketing. Achieving the map position requires a combination of onsite quality, offsite metrics, and Google’s local algorithm. Being on top can determine whether your law firm is found but also, whether word of mouth referrals see your high ratings and reviews.

Google is constantly tweaking their algorithms to find a way to exhibit the best user experience possible. These adjustments can and will affect the way your firm is ranking and most marketers and businesses that engage in search marketing practices have come to expect moderate turbulence. However, the past month has been an abnormally tumultuous time for law firms ranking on the local map on Google.

In May, I built an index of 195 websites that were ranking in the top 3 (3-pack) in various cities and practice areas. This week on the heels of a shaky September and the Google Penguin 4.0 release, I ran the test again and saw significantly different results.

An astounding 52.8% of law firms previously in the 3-pack have disappeared.

Google Possum
This algorithm update seems to primarily affect local search. The SEO community has decided to call this algorithm “Possum”, possibly due to the fact that local business listings seemingly disappeared from the local map. Fear not, your listings have not been erased, just filtered.

The specifics of this update are still unclear, but some changes have been defined. Some businesses that fall out of the physical city limits have had their rankings increased. Google now believes that a high quality website with solid metrics and an office a few miles out of city limits can now compete with the downtown law firms. This change has helped some suburban law firms qualify for a metro keyword. Search results also differ more based on various keyphrase formats. Prior to Possum, “Houston Personal Injury Attorney” and “Personal Injury Attorney in Houston” would generally yield the same results. It seems now that this has changed.

houston-personal-injury-attorney-google-search123

Another major algorithm update that could be related to the changes to local search is Penguin 4.0. It was officially confirmed on September 23. Penguin 4.0 is a big deal among search marketers because it is formally integrated into Google’s core algorithm - meaning Google will never announce another Penguin-related update again and the functions of Penguin will be in real-time.

Local Map Search Experiment
When I first compiled the list of top local law firms, I had no idea that it would be the last time I’d see some of them. In order to compile this catalog, I chose the five cities with the highest population - New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago, Houston and Philadelphia. I also chose eight other cities - Miami, Cleveland, San Francisco, Phoenix, Dallas, Atlanta, Oakland and Seattle to see if the algorithm would affect them as much as the highest populated cities. I then picked competitive areas of practice such as Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Estate Planning, DUI and Divorce. Lawyer and Attorney were alternated for each search. I composed the top 3 law firms shown on the local map, bringing the total to 195 law firms.

untitled-spreadsheet-google-sheets

When the turbulence of local rank changes began forming, I immediately rebooted this experiment to see how severe the adjustment would be. To my surprise, 103, or 52.8% of law firms previously ranked in the top 3 of the local map were no longer there. This signified that it wasn’t just a regular correction Google made, this is an update that is changing the landscape of local search.

About Author

Dexter Tam is a staff contributor for Bigger Law Firm Magazine and is a Search Analyst for Custom Legal Marketing.

  • Lisa Banks

    Dexter, what a fun post! It was great to see the changing results deconstructed. Probably the hardest part about this sort of turbulence is that it makes attorneys and their search firms think “Well, what should I do differently, then?” The answer is most likely “nothing”. Keep focusing on the factors you CAN impact, like a high-quality, optimized website that serves your target audience and engagement with that audience offsite, too.

    • Dexter Tam

      Hey Lisa, thanks for the comment! I agree that focusing on optimization that are tried and true like the ones you mentioned is often times the best method.

      “Keep Calm and Market On”

Download the Latest Bigger Law Firm Magazine, FREE!

Want to download the full issue of Bigger Law Firm Magazine? Signup for This Week on BLF and you will receive a download link for our latest issue. 

Thank you for signing up for This Week on BLF! Download the latest issue at http://blfmag.com/BLFMag44

More in Search Marketing
The Ethics of Online Client Communication

There are a number of benefits to using cloud-based messenger services for client meetings. For instance, an app such as Skype allows lawyers to schedule...

Close